by Marianne Sundquist on
NOTHING FEELS ORDINARY WHEN YOU walk into Mad Jack’s Mountaintop Barbecue. The golden glow of holiday lights wrapped around wooden beams and the enticing smell of oak smoldering in the pits lets you know you’re in for something special.
On the morning I visit the popular Cloudcroft establishment, owner James Jackson carries his coffee outside to chat with folks starting to gather on the wooden porch. By the time the doors open for business two hours later, Jackson is positioned behind the cafeteria-style line with his crew in the open kitchen, welcoming guests as they walk through the door, asking what brought them to town. As I watch him sling his signature smoked meats for a seemingly never-ending line of hungry guests, perhaps what is most striking is his genuine interest and delight in everyone he meets.
Although Jackson grew up in the barbecue capital of Texas, he spent 30 years working at his dad’s car dealership in Lockhart. When Chrysler filed for bankruptcy in 2009, his family lost their car franchise. With it went Jackson’s dream of taking over the family business.
“I told Lockhart not to worry about me,” he says. Yet his goals were modest when he packed up to start a barbecue joint in New Mexico after a childhood spent vacationing here. “I had visions of me and one employee waiting for customers. Maybe three or four people would walk in while we’d be playing dominos or cards,” he says. “We’d get up to help them, then go back to our game. But when we opened the weekend before Memorial Day 2015, we rocked from the first day and have been busy ever since.”
Today, the space has an inexplicable feeling of nostalgia, no matter where you’re from. Family and BBQ-related photographs, signs, posters, and objects fill the walls, climbing their way into the rafters. The dining table that belonged to Jackson’s mother sits in the middle of the room, and anyone who visits is welcome to pull up a chair to this beloved heirloom.
Mad Jack’s pulled pork, pork ribs, “dinosaur” beef ribs, turkey, chicken, and sausages are gently smoked throughout the night starting around 8:30 p.m., coming off the pits just long enough for the meat to rest before the team starts pulling out red butcher paper and slicing it to order the next morning. But some might say that it’s Jackson’s brisket that draws two- to three-hour lines on the weekends.
“I don’t know what you do,” I overhear a guest telling Jackson, “but I’m from Texas, and this is the best bark I’ve ever had.” The 62-year-old pitmaster smiles as he weighs brisket on a digital scale and hands a paper boat of blackened beef to the man across the counter. Later, I ask Jackson what makes his brisket so sought-after, even from people who come from places famous for BBQ.
“I remember when I was trying to learn how to cook a brisket,” he recalls. “I thought, I’m gonna do it better than all these up-and-coming Lockhart guys.” He looked up competitive pitmaster recipes and tried a variety of complicated rubs for his meats, but none of them turned out very well. “Then I remembered that the old Lockhart pitmasters mostly just used salt and pepper,” he says. “It was the best brisket I ever made. There’s nothing very complicated about what we do—salt, pepper, wood, and fire.”
Jackson’s devotion to authentic Central Texas BBQ means he drives 644 miles every six to eight weeks to pick up Central Texas post oak, the mildest of barbecue smoking woods. But he doesn’t shy away from adding a bit of New Mexico to the mix.
On the day I visited, the special was a customer-requested brisket green chile stew. The broth was rich and satisfying, with generous chunks of brisket and the familiar flavor and heat of New Mexico green chile throughout. Mad Jack’s daily menu also has half a dozen sandwiches, including chopped brisket topped with mac and cheese. Sides include all the classics, like potato salads, loaded baked potatoes, coleslaw, and pinto beans.
Gracie Jo Grey, Mad Jack’s baker and Jackson’s fiancée, makes all the fruit cobblers and corn bread from scratch, including a green chile variety that often sells out before the pan goes from the oven to the line. “This summer, we’re going to build a mini bakery, and Gracie wants to start baking breads in-house,” Jackson says. By 3 p.m. most afternoons, they are sold out of everything.
“Maybe the other guys are smarter businessmen than me, but I’ve never been in this for the money,” Jackson says. In fact, when a customer recently asked about his secret for success, Jackson didn’t have an answer. “But later, I thought about it and realized I love what I do, I love people, and I have a great crew,” he says. That’s why it’s important that he greets customers outside, opens the door in the mornings, and takes their orders. “We care a heck of a lot about how a person feels when they leave here.”
Everything about Mad Jack’s Mountaintop Barbecue was enough to inspire me to try to create a bit of this magic at home. A big thanks to Jackson and Grey for sharing their signature pork rub and cobbler recipes.