by Sarah Mock on
THE BEST WAY TO VISIT The Mouse Hole Cheese Shop in Albuquerque is to come hungry and open-minded. Cheesemonger David Myers loves nothing more than to guide guests, taste buds first, through the dozens of cheeses in his case.
“Working in cheese is kind of like sharing a secret,” Myers says. “Did you know that cheese can taste like cotton candy or asparagus or roast beef? That’s the magic of fermentation. It’s like Willy Wonka in real life.”
He offers a sample of Red Butte Hatch Chile cheddar from Beehive Cheese in Utah, which is studded with chiles and rubbed with coriander and red chile powder, and an exotic Sardinian goat cheese served with a tangy Basque cherry. He recommends that you warm the cheese in your hand for a moment, all the better to enjoy the rich palette of flavors in every sliver.
“You’ll taste the cheese, you get the stories and history behind it, and then you get to take it home,” says co-owner Mekala Kennedy of the Mouse Hole experience.
Kennedy and her husband, Nathan Sauceda-Halliday, both spent their careers in restaurants. But after moving back to Sauceda-Halliday’s hometown of Albuquerque about a decade ago, they missed the cut-to-order cheese shop they frequented when they first met in California. So, in 2022, they decided to fill that niche just 520 mouse steps away from their first culinary venture, La Finca Bowls, on Broadway Boulevard.
Despite having an expertly curated national and international cheese selection, the couple was enthusiastic about representing local producers as well. But they soon learned that local artisanal cheeses are harder to come by.
“There are really interesting small producers in the state that are, unfortunately, mostly not certified to bring their cheeses to market,” Sauceda-Halliday says. The pair were anxious to do something about this, but with two shops to run, they knew they couldn’t do it on their own. So when the couple met Lissa Knudsen, a lifelong dairy lover and experienced organizer, they were thrilled to support her work in founding the New Mexico Cheese Guild.
Knudsen says that although the Land of Enchantment is already the fourth-largest cheese producer in the U.S., the vast majority of that cheese comes from large-scale dairies and goes to mass-market products. Due to the costs and regulatory hurdles of certifying dairy facilities, artisanal dairies and cheesemakers have struggled in the state—but that’s something the guild is aiming to change. “Our mission is to support and grow future cheesemakers in New Mexico,” Knudsen explains.
Since its launch in early 2023, the nonprofit has hosted community cheese tastings, won a grant to purchase a refrigerated cheese truck, and advanced Albuquerque’s raw milk ordinance, which allows for the sale of unpasteurized milk in grocery stores and markets in the city (though dairies still need a New Mexico Department of Agriculture permit). “People are looking for education, resources, and honestly, a community to support them so they don’t give up,” Knudsen says. “That’s what we’re doing.”
The guild is also taking a communal approach to helping revitalize New Mexico’s rich cheesemaking traditions. For example, some of New Mexico’s oldest known cheeses originated with Diné people. One such cheese was traditionally made with goat’s milk and possibly flavored with sweet fern, giving it a delicate, resinous flavor. Although these cheeses are not commercially available today, Native artisans still know the recipes. Guild members hope heritage varieties like these will reemerge as the local cheese community grows.
Beyond spreading an appreciation for the dairy arts, the guild also aims to empower local dairies and cheesemakers to bring their products to market, which requires meeting USDA food safety requirements.
In an effort to become more self-sufficient, Amanda Brown, owner of Brown’s Micro-Creamery in Corrales, began raising dairy goats a decade ago. When the daily milk haul started to outpace her family’s appetite, she fell in love with the art of cheesemaking.
“I’m not very good at following recipes,” Brown says, “and for cheese, the recipe matters.” Not just the ingredients, but factors like timing, storage, humidity, and temperature are also critical to crafting safe and delicious cheeses. Brown specializes in chèvre, a soft, fresh cheese that she makes with raw milk from her goats. She’s had the chance to learn from world-class artisans, including natural cheesemaker David Asher, who recently hosted a local workshop supported by the guild.
However, certification requirements—which can cost $30,000 to $100,000—have kept Brown’s cheeses out of shops like the Mouse Hole. The guild, where Brown currently serves as treasurer, is helping cheesemakers like her leverage their skills and collaborations to create more affordable paths toward certification.
Nancy Coonridge, a dairywoman who’s been raising goats and making cheese in the Pie Town area for decades, has experienced the challenges of dairying in the state firsthand. Still, she is optimistic about the guild’s potential to help new producers.
“The beauty of the guild is that maybe we could have a place where people could process milk and cheese without having to buy all the equipment,” Coonridge says. The guild’s new refrigerated cheese truck is a good example, given that this essential tool for safe cheese distribution can cost in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Despite these challenges, New Mexico’s unique climate and geography lend themselves to good cheeses. Grazing practices, certain airborne bacteria, and the dry, high-altitude environment contribute to the cultivation of cheeses with one-of-a-kind flavors. These factors are part of the reason Coonridge settled here and why guild members are so excited about the state’s cheesemaking potential.
“Within one year, our cheese cultures will evolve unique traits that aren’t found anywhere else on Earth,” cheesemonger Myers says. “That’s that taste of place—the cultural identity that will grow only here in New Mexico.”
Sarah Mock is an Albuquerque-based writer and podcaster focused on food and agriculture.